· Atlas des Trésors
Cyprus: two Byzantine icons from Asinou, stolen after the 1974 invasion, returned after fifty years
St Matthew and St Mark are back. Painted in the fourteenth century for the church at Asinou, in the Troodos mountains, these two icons vanished from Kyrenia after 1974. Traced to the United Kingdom, they have been returned free of charge to the Bishopric of Morphou. Four panels from the same series are still missing.

For more than fifty years, their place stood empty. Two fourteenth-century Byzantine icons depicting the Evangelists St Matthew and St Mark have been officially handed over to the Bishopric of Morphou in Cyprus, the Cyprus Mail reported on 4 November 2026. Painted for the church of the Panagia Phorviotissa at Asinou, in the Troodos mountains, they disappeared after the Turkish invasion of 1974. They were traced to the United Kingdom, and their holder agreed to give them back without asking for any compensation. It is a rare restitution, and it closes a small part of a much larger wound: the looting of the religious heritage of the north of the island.
Two Evangelists from a Great Deesis
The two panels are works of the Palaiologan period, that is, the final centuries of the Byzantine Empire. They are painted in egg tempera and gold leaf on wood. According to Medievalists.net, the icon of St Matthew measures 63 × 51 cm, and that of St Mark 63.5 × 47.5 cm.
They were not made as stand-alone works. They belonged to a Great Deesis, a series of icons showing Christ surrounded by the Virgin, St John the Baptist, the apostles and the evangelists. Every lost panel therefore leaves a gap in a set conceived as a whole, which makes the series both precious and difficult to reassemble.
Asinou, one of the painted churches of the Troodos
The church of the Panagia Phorviotissa, better known as Panagia tis Asinou, stands near the village of Nikitari, in the foothills of the Troodos. According to the Cyprus Mail, the monastery it belonged to was founded in 1099, and the church itself was built in the early twelfth century. Its interior preserves Byzantine wall paintings from the twelfth to the seventeenth century.
The building is one of the Painted Churches in the Troodos Region, a UNESCO World Heritage Site. This serial property brings together ten churches. UNESCO notes that at Asinou, the fourteenth-century wall paintings blend local and Western influences with the revived art of Palaiologan Constantinople. The two returned icons are therefore contemporary with this phase of the decoration: they belong to the same artistic moment as the frescoes that still cover the walls.
Moved to safety… and stolen
The paradox of this story is that the icons were stolen where they were thought to be safer. Before the 1974 invasion, they had been moved from Asinou to the premises of the Metropolis of Kyrenia, on the island's north coast. After the invasion, Kyrenia found itself in the part of the country occupied by the Turkish army, and it was there that the two panels were stolen, then smuggled out of Cyprus.
The sources do not say who stole them, or exactly when, or by what route they reached Britain. Nor is it known how many hands they passed through in half a century. The articles published in October and November 2026 say only that their movements were documented, which made it possible to have the rights of the Church of Cyprus over the works recognised.
Found in the United Kingdom, returned free of charge
The return was first announced by the Bishopric of Morphou on 9 October 2026, "with great emotion", according to the Orthodox news agency quoted by OrthoChristian. The outcome was made public in early November: the icons were officially handed over to the Bishopric of Morphou, completing a return awaited for more than five decades.
The most remarkable point remains the attitude of the holder. Neither their name nor the city where the icons were kept has been made public. But according to Medievalists.net, the holder agreed to surrender them "without seeking financial compensation". In restitution cases, this is far from the rule: many cases drag on for years in the courts, or are settled by a buy-back.
Several people were credited for their role in this return:
- the Byzantine scholar Christodoulos Hadjichristodoulou;
- the art historian Maria Paphiti, formerly of Christie's;
- Bishop Porphyrios of Neapolis;
- the lawyer Giorgos Hadjipieris, who coordinated the legal process.
The Cyprus Department of Antiquities and its director George Georgiou, the Cyprus police and Interpol also helped, as did the theologian and iconographer George Petrou, according to the Cyprus Mail.
Present at the handover, the lawyer Giorgos Hadjipieris summed up the event with an image: this time, "the river had a reverse direction, it returned to the source". Bishop Neophytos of Morphou saw in it a spiritual lesson: "This is how God works, through trials both of the fatherland and personal."
A series still incomplete
Matthew and Mark are not the first panels of the Asinou Deesis to come home. In 2007, two other icons from the same series, the apostles Peter and Paul, were repatriated from New York. The Cyprus Mail reported at the time that Church investigators had spotted a group of Cypriot icons in a Sotheby's sale catalogue. They came from the collection of the Pankow Foundation, created by the businessman Charles Pankow, and the auction house had been asked to halt the sale. Of the six icons returned at a ceremony in New York in January 2007, five came from Asinou. It was already the Bishop of Morphou who received them.
An icon of Christ Pantocrator from the series also survives. But four panels are still missing: those of the Virgin, St John the Baptist, St John the Theologian and St Luke. Their whereabouts are unknown, and the Church of Cyprus is still searching for them.
Looting on a vast scale
This return is part of a struggle Cyprus has waged since 1974. For decades, the Department of Antiquities has been trying to trace the religious and cultural objects torn from churches and sites in the north after the invasion. The scale of the phenomenon is considerable: in 2024, Michalis Gavrielidis, director of the Cypriot office for combating the illegal possession and trafficking of antiquities, estimated that more than 16,000 Christian icons, mosaics and murals had been stolen and sold abroad since 1974.
The best-known case is that of the Turkish trafficker Aydin Dikmen. In 1997, the investigation in Munich led to the seizure of 318 objects of Cypriot origin linked to his network: sixth-century mosaics, frescoes from the eighth to the fifteenth century, icons, doors, manuscripts and prehistoric objects. It took years of legal proceedings before these works came back in waves, in 2013, in 2015, then a final batch of 60 pieces after an agreement signed in 2024. Nothing in the sources, however, links the icons of Matthew and Mark to that case.
What we know, what we don't
What we know: the two icons date from the fourteenth century, come from the Great Deesis of Asinou, were stolen in Kyrenia after 1974, found in the United Kingdom and returned free of charge to the Bishopric of Morphou, which announced their return in October 2026.
What we don't know: the identity of the holder and how they had acquired them, the route the works took between 1974 and today, the exact date and place of the official handover, and where the icons will be kept or displayed. Nor do the sources say whether they will one day return to their place in the church at Asinou.
One certainty remains: until the Virgin, St John the Baptist, St John the Theologian and St Luke are found, the Great Deesis of Asinou will remain incomplete. Those four panels have become, for the Church of Cyprus as for art historians, a true lost treasure.
Sources
- Cyprus Mail: Two 14th-century icons stolen in 1974 returned to Cyprus (4 November 2026)
- Medievalists.net: Two Stolen Byzantine Icons Returned to Cyprus After 50 Years (30 October 2026)
- Cyprus Mail: Two 14th-century icons stolen after Turkish invasion return to Cyprus (9 October 2026)
- OrthoChristian: Two Byzantine icons repatriated to Cyprus (14 October 2026)
- Cyprus Mail (archive): Stolen icons handed over in New York ceremony (12 January 2007)
- Cyprus Mail: 60 looted Cyprus antiquities to be returned (11 June 2024)
- UNESCO: Painted Churches in the Troodos Region
Hungary: 208 Celtic silver coins found 40 cm underground, beneath a future power substation in Szombathely
Sutton Hoo: a new Anglo-Saxon grave, with brooch, knife and tweezers, found far from the royal mounds
Havmanden wreck: a luxury shoe and manillas on the Danish ship of the 1683 mutiny