Skip to contentAtlas des Trésors

Practical guide · updated on

Pirate treasure: the legends and the facts

A chest buried on an island, a map marked with a cross, a cryptogram thrown to the crowd before the hanging: the image of pirate treasure is everywhere. The reality is rarer: the most famous hoard, Captain Kidd’s, was seized and inventoried as early as 1699. Here is what the sources say about the great pirates and their treasures.

Did pirates bury their treasure?

Rarely. A specialist interviewed by the magazine Texas Highways points out that pirates hardly ever buried their loot. It was shared out, and could even be handed back: after the capture of a rich Portuguese ship in 1721, Captain John Taylor’s crew surrendered almost all of its share in exchange for an amnesty.

The image of the buried chest owes a great deal to literature and to a few real episodes, first among them that of Captain Kidd. It was kept alive by accounts published long after the events, such as A General History of the Pyrates in 1724, and by documents that surfaced in the 20th century. The Atlas entries always separate what is established from what the story says; they are gathered in the theme Pirate and privateer treasures.

Captain Kidd: a treasure really buried, and seized

William Kidd, born around 1645 in Greenock, Scotland, was hired in 1695 by London investors for a privateering voyage in the Indian Ocean. During this voyage he seized, among others, the Quedagh Merchant. At the end of 1698 the Crown declared these privateers pirates.

Before reaching Boston, where he had been promised a pardon, Kidd buried part of his loot on Gardiners Island, off Long Island. Arrested shortly after his arrival, in July 1699, he saw this deposit seized: on 25 July 1699, Governor Bellomont drew up its inventory, more than 200 silver bars, an enamelled silver box set with diamonds, a diamond ring and 67 rubies. Kidd was hanged in London on 23 May 1701.

What belongs to legend: the other treasures. From prison, Kidd offered to go back and fetch a treasure of £50,000 or £60,000, which Bellomont refused; its existence has never been proven. In the 19th century, American newspapers placed hiding places of Kidd’s as far as near Albany, and the legend set off treasure hunts from Maryland to Nova Scotia. All were in vain.

Blackbeard: “only he and the Devil”

Edward Teach, known as Blackbeard, raided the West Indies and the American coast in 1717 and 1718. He captured the French slave ship La Concorde, which he renamed Queen Anne’s Revenge, and blockaded the port of Charleston for nearly a week in May 1718. He was killed in hand-to-hand fighting on 22 November 1718 at Ocracoke, North Carolina.

According to A General History of the Pyrates, on the eve of his death one of his men asked him whether his wife knew where he had buried his money; he replied that only he and the Devil knew. The anecdote cannot be verified. The wreck attributed to the Queen Anne’s Revenge, located in 1996 near Beaufort Inlet, has yielded cannons and objects from the ship, but less than an ounce of gold dust: no treasure.

Samuel Bellamy and the Whydah: the wreck of a pirate ship

The best-known pirate loot comes, for its part, from a wreck. A slave ship captured by the crew of Samuel “Black Sam” Bellamy in early 1717, the Whydah was wrecked in a storm off Cape Cod on 26 April 1717; only two men survived. Located in 1984 by Barry Clifford’s team, the wreck was identified in 1985 thanks to its bell, inscribed “The Whydah Gally 1716”. Some 15,000 coins have been raised from it. Barry Clifford claims that most of the loot is still under the sand: a claim that has not been independently confirmed.

La Buse: a cryptogram that appeared in 1934

The French pirate Olivier Levasseur, known as La Buse (“the Buzzard”), took part in April 1721, with Captain John Taylor, in the capture of the Nossa Senhora do Cabo, a Portuguese ship under repair off Saint-Denis, on Île Bourbon, carrying the Portuguese viceroy of the Indies and the archbishop of Goa. According to the researcher Carola Dahlke, it was Taylor who led the operation; his crew then surrendered almost all of its share of the loot in exchange for an amnesty. La Buse was hanged at Saint-Paul, on Réunion, in 1730.

Legend has it that he threw a cryptogram to the crowd, shouting “My treasure to whoever can take it!”. But this cryptogram first appeared in 1934, in a book by Charles de La Roncière; no contemporary source mentions it and no manuscript of it exists. The treasure has since been placed in the Seychelles, Madagascar, Mauritius, Rodrigues or Réunion. In 2025, a wreck off the island of Sainte-Marie, Madagascar, was presented as that of the Nossa Senhora do Cabo; the identification is disputed.

Jean Lafitte: the privateer of Galveston

Jean Lafitte, born around 1780, probably in France, led from about 1810 a band of smugglers and privateers based in Barataria Bay, south of New Orleans. He fought alongside Andrew Jackson at the Battle of New Orleans on 8 January 1815, and was then pardoned. From 1817 to 1820, he made Galveston Island, in Texas, into a base called Campeche.

Local stories credit him with a treasure buried on the island, at a place once called Three Trees, or whose clues are said to be held by a skull kept in an antiques shop. Nothing confirms it. A letter of 1853, kept in Galveston, even describes a “magnetism” session during which the location of the treasure was supposedly revealed. Lafitte owes his reputation mainly to fiction and film, from Byron to The Buccaneer.

The treasure of Lima and Cocos Island

According to a widespread story, riches from Lima entrusted around 1820–1821 to the British captain William Thompson, of the Mary Dear, were stolen and hidden on Cocos Island, off Costa Rica. None of the sources consulted by the Atlas cites a contemporary document attesting this treasure of Lima. More than 300 expeditions are said to have searched the island, without result; the German captain August Gissler lived there from 1889 to 1908 and found only a few Spanish coins. Today the island is a national park on UNESCO’s World Heritage List, strictly protected, where treasure hunting is forbidden.

Oak Island: a “Money Pit” with no money

On Oak Island, in Nova Scotia, a teenager is said to have discovered in 1795 a depression revealing a filled-in shaft. More than two centuries of digging, flooded by the sea, have yielded no treasure; four searchers died there in 1965. The Oak Island treasure has been attributed in turn to Kidd, Henry Morgan, Blackbeard, the Templars or the Freemasons: hypotheses considered speculative. In 1995, a study by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution attributed the flooding to a natural phenomenon.

The privateers of Saint-Malo

France had its privateers. At the entrance to Saint-Malo, the wrecks of La Natière are those of two privateer frigates: the Dauphine, built at the royal dockyard in Le Havre and entrusted by Louis XIV to shipowners for privateering, lost in 1704, and the Aimable Grenot, fitted out as a privateer until 1748 and then converted to trade, lost in 1749. Their excavation, from 1999 to 2008, yielded no chest of gold, but several thousand objects of life on board: tableware, tools, apothecary’s equipment, cannons, sabres and pistols. In practice, this is what the “treasure” of a privateer ship looks like.

Key points

  1. The best-documented hoard is Kidd’s on Gardiners Island, seized and inventoried in 1699.
  2. Wrecks are the real source of pirate loot, like the Whydah, not hiding places on land.
  3. Many clues are late: Blackbeard’s anecdote dates from 1724, La Buse’s cryptogram from 1934.
  4. The sites are protected: Cocos Island bans treasure hunting, Oak Island regulates it by law, and in France any excavation and any object found at sea fall under the Heritage Code (see I found a treasure: what does the law say?).

Looking for pirate treasure… legally

The theme inspires organised treasure hunts. The Atlas directory lists, for example, Le Secret des Pirates, whose riddles are printed on a shirt, Gold & Crystal, linked to a pirate video game and hidden in the Caribbean, or La croix de la liberté, on the trail of the pirates’ republic of Libertalia. Their dates and rules are on their entries; see also our guide Treasure hunts running in 2027. For wrecks, see Treasure galleons and shipwrecks.

Sources and fact-checking14 sources · guide checked on 11 November 2026
  1. 1Atlas des TrésorsEntries for the legends and wrecks mentioned, each with its own sources and date of checkingatlasdestresors.fr
  2. 2Encyclopaedia Britannica« William Kidd »britannica.com
  3. 3Adam Matthew Digital, after Bellomont’s letter (The National Archives, CO 5/1043)« In Search of Captain Kidd’s Lost Treasure »amdigital.co.uk
  4. 4NCpedia« Blackbeard the Pirate »ncpedia.org
  5. 5Smithsonian Magazine« Did Archaeologists Uncover Blackbeard’s Treasure? »smithsonianmag.com
  6. 6Project Gutenberg, Charles Johnson« A General History of the Pyrates » (1724)gutenberg.org
  7. 7Smithsonian Magazine« Scholars discover six skeletons in Whydah pirate ship »smithsonianmag.com
  8. 8Bibliothèque municipale de Lyon, Guichet du savoir« Que sait-on aujourd’hui du trésor qu’aurait caché le pirate Olivier Levasseur dit La Buse »guichetdusavoir.org
  9. 9Texas Highways« Jean Lafitte in Galveston »texashighways.com
  10. 10Galveston & Texas History Center, Rosenberg Library« Jean Laffite »galvestonhistorycenter.org
  11. 11Explorersweb« Exploration Mysteries: The Treasure of Lima »explorersweb.com
  12. 12UNESCO World Heritage Centre« Cocos Island National Park »whc.unesco.org
  13. 13The Canadian Encyclopedia« Oak Island »thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  14. 14French Ministry of Culture, Underwater archaeology« La Natière (1704-1749), Saint-Malo »archeologie.culture.gouv.fr

Each fact in the text links to its sources by number. Links open in a new tab.