Legend
The legend of the Treasure of Lima
Story of riches evacuated from Lima around 1820 aboard the Mary Dear and hidden on Cocos Island (Costa Rica)
StatusNo treasure has been found and no source consulted cites any contemporary document attesting to it; Cocos Island is a strictly protected national park where treasure hunting is banned.
According to a widespread story, riches from Lima entrusted around 1820-1821 to the British captain William Thompson were stolen and hidden on Cocos Island. No source consulted cites any contemporary document attesting to this treasure, and more than 300 expeditions have found nothing.
What is established
- The story is set at the time when the independence fighters were threatening Lima, in 1820 according to PBS and Explorersweb, in 1821 according to National Geographic. None of these sources cites any contemporary document attesting to the treasure or its burial.123
- The German captain August Gissler lived on the island from 1889 to 1908; Costa Rica appointed him governor and allowed him to found a colony there, which failed. He found only a few Spanish coins.23
- More than 300 expeditions are said to have searched the island, without result.123
- Costa Rica banned treasure hunting on the island in 1994 according to Explorersweb; PBS states that the government no longer issues licences.23
- Cocos Island National Park, inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List in 1997, is strictly protected and managed by the Costa Rican national parks service; human presence is limited to park staff, scientists and visitors.24
What the story says
Tales and traditions, presented as such: they are not established facts.
- According to the story, the viceroy entrusted the riches of Lima to the British captain William Thompson, of the Mary Dear, who got rid of the guards and priests and hid the loot on Cocos Island. PBS reports a value of 12 to 60 million dollars attributed to Spanish officers, without reference; National Geographic gives 60 million.123
- Still according to the story, a Spanish ship captured the Mary Dear and the crew were hanged for piracy (in Panama according to National Geographic), except Thompson and his mate, who promised to guide the Spaniards and then escaped onto the island; National Geographic has them picked up by a whaler in 1822.12
- The mate, James Alexander Forbes, is said to have reached California and left directions to his descendants (family tradition). Explorersweb cites a document in a Caracas museum detailing the treasure, with no date and no means of verification, and suggests that these stories may have been used to mislead the authorities.13
How the story unfolds
- 1820-1821Independence fighters threaten Lima; date of the evacuation story (1820 for PBS and Explorersweb, 1821 for National Geographic).
- 1822According to National Geographic, Thompson and Forbes are picked up on the island by a whaler (story).
- 1889-1908August Gissler lives on the island.
- 1994Treasure hunting is banned on the island (according to Explorersweb).
- 1997The national park is inscribed on the UNESCO World Heritage List (according to PBS NOVA).
Sources and fact-checking4 sources · entry checked on 3 November 2026
- 1National Geographic (15 septembre 2026)« How a Colonial Hoard of Gold Ended Up as Buried Treasure »nationalgeographic.com
- 2PBS NOVA« Island of the Sharks : Legends and Lore (2) »pbs.org
- 3Explorersweb« Exploration Mysteries: The Treasure of Lima »explorersweb.com
- 4UNESCO, Centre du patrimoine mondial« Cocos Island National Park »whc.unesco.org
Each fact in the text links to its sources by number. Links open in a new tab.