Skip to contentAtlas des Trésors

Lost treasure

The Just Judges panel

Panel of the Adoration of the Mystic Lamb altarpiece stolen in 1934 from St Bavo's Cathedral in Ghent

The Just Judges panel
Jan van Eyck, old photograph, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

StatusThe panel has never been found; a copy painted during the Second World War replaces it in the altarpiece, and the investigation remains open.

On the night of 10 April 1934, two panels of the Van Eyck brothers' Adoration of the Mystic Lamb altarpiece were stolen from St Bavo's Cathedral in Ghent. The Saint John the Baptist was returned a few weeks later by the blackmailer, but the Just Judges have never been found.

On display at: St Bavo's Cathedral, GhentGhent, Belgium

What is established

  • The Adoration of the Mystic Lamb altarpiece, by the brothers Hubert and Jan van Eyck, was installed on 6 May 1432 in the chapel of Joos Vijd and Elisabeth Borluut, in what is now St Bavo's Cathedral.1
  • On the night of 10 April 1934, the Just Judges were stolen together with the panel of Saint John the Baptist, which formed its reverse until they were separated in the nineteenth century. The theft was discovered on the morning of 11 April.234
  • A blackmailer signing himself “D.U.A.” demanded one million Belgian francs from the bishopric in a series of letters. To prove that he held the work, he had the Saint John the Baptist collected from a railway station left-luggage office at the end of May 1934.234
  • The negotiations failed, owing in particular to the firm stance of the Minister of Justice, Paul-Émile Janson.3
  • On 25 November 1934, Arsène Goedertier, a stockbroker from Wetteren, died in Dendermonde after a stroke; in his last moments, he claimed to be the only one who knew where the panel was. Copies of the ransom letters were found in his office.234
  • The panel visible in the altarpiece today is a copy made during the Second World War by the restorer Jef Van der Veken. The altarpiece is displayed in the cathedral's Chapel of the Blessed Sacrament.14

What is assumed

Debated interpretations, presented as such.

  • Goedertier, probably the instigator, could not have carried out the theft alone according to The Art Newspaper; his possible accomplices have never been identified and his motive remains obscure.4
  • Successive leads have placed the panel in or near the cathedral (an excavation under the Kalandeberg square in 2019 found nothing), in Wetteren, in the royal crypt or with a Ghent family; one journalist says it was destroyed in 1971. None has been confirmed.24
  • One theory, without proof, holds that the copy in place is in fact the original, returned after the negotiations failed.4

The treasure’s journey

  1. 6 May 1432The altarpiece is installed in the Vijd chapel.
  2. 10-11 April 1934Theft of the Just Judges and the Saint John the Baptist.
  3. late May 1934The Saint John the Baptist is recovered from a station left-luggage office.
  4. 25 November 1934Death of Arsène Goedertier, who says he knows the hiding place.
  5. 2008A floor in Ghent is searched after a tip-off, without result.
  6. 2019Fruitless excavation at the Kalandeberg, near the cathedral.

Nearby

Sources and fact-checking4 sources · entry checked on 3 November 2026
  1. 1Cathédrale Saint-Bavon de Gand« The Ghent Altarpiece »sintbaafskathedraal.be
  2. 2VRT NWS (Colin Clapson, 13 avril 2024)« The mystery of the disappearance of the Just Judges 90 years on »vrt.be
  3. 3Belga News Agency (vers le 11 avril 2022)« 88 years and counting: will the Ghent Altarpiece ever be complete again? »belganewsagency.eu
  4. 4The Art Newspaper (Noah Charney, 22 août 2018)« Lost art: chasing the elusive Ghent Altarpiece panel »theartnewspaper.com

Each fact in the text links to its sources by number. Links open in a new tab.