Lost treasure
Caravaggio's Nativity
Painting stolen in October 1969 from the Oratorio di San Lorenzo in Palermo, never recovered
.jpg?width=1280)
StatusThe painting has never been recovered; since December 2015, a replica made by the Factum Arte workshop has taken its place in the oratory.
The Nativity with Saint Francis and Saint Lawrence, painted by Caravaggio, adorned the high altar of the Oratorio di San Lorenzo in Palermo. In October 1969, two thieves cut it from its frame; despite more than fifty years of investigations, it has never been found.
What is established
- Caravaggio painted the Nativity with Saint Francis and Saint Lawrence for the high altar of the Oratorio di San Lorenzo; it is dated 1609 (Artnet, Città metropolitana di Palermo) or between 1600 and 1609 (Smithsonian). The canvas is nearly nine feet high, about 2.7 m.124
- On the night of 17 October 1969, two thieves cut the canvas out of its frame, above the altar, and carried it off rolled up in a rug taken on the spot.12
- The theft is generally attributed to the Sicilian Mafia, without certainty; others suspect amateurs, attracted by a mention of its value on television a few weeks earlier.123
- The FBI, Interpol and the Italian police have been investigating for more than five decades. In 2005, the FBI listed this theft among its top ten art crimes; it values the painting at 20 million dollars.2
- An enlarged photograph took the painting's place for 46 years. In December 2015, a replica made by the Factum Arte workshop, commissioned by the Sky channel, replaced it; the President of the Republic, Sergio Mattarella, was announced to unveil it.123
What is assumed
Debated interpretations, presented as such.
- According to the former mafioso Gaetano Grado, speaking in 2018, amateur thieves handed the painting over to the Mafia boss Gaetano Badalamenti, who is said to have sold it to a Swiss dealer; the president of the parliamentary anti-Mafia commission, Rosy Bindi, then considered that the painting might be intact.12
- Other versions, including those of informants, say it was destroyed: eaten by rats or pigs on a farm, burned, or lost in the Irpinia earthquake of 1980. None has been verified.123
- According to the Mafia turncoat Francesco Marino Mannoia (2005), a buyer is said to have commissioned the theft and then backed out because of the damage done to the canvas.2
The treasure’s journey
- 1609Date of execution adopted by Artnet and the Città metropolitana di Palermo.
- 17 October 1969The painting is stolen from the Oratorio di San Lorenzo.
- 2005The FBI lists the theft among its top ten art crimes.
- December 2015The Factum Arte replica is installed, replacing a photograph.
- 2018Gaetano Grado speaks of a sale to a Swiss dealer.
Nearby
Sources and fact-checking4 sources · entry checked on 3 November 2026
- 1Smithsonian Magazine« New Clues Emerge in Search for Stolen Caravaggio »smithsonianmag.com
- 2Artnet News (Verity Babbs)« The Hunt: Is Caravaggio's $20 Million Nativity Scene Lost to the Underworld? »news.artnet.com
- 3Artnet News (Henri Neuendorf)« Caravaggio Masterpiece Stolen in Notorious Mafia Heist Replaced with Replica »news.artnet.com
- 4Città metropolitana di Palermo, portail touristique (Bianca Di Pietro)« Oratorio di San Lorenzo – Aperto al pubblico »turismo.cittametropolitana.pa.it
Each fact in the text links to its sources by number. Links open in a new tab.